A fresh sports hearing and a returning panel member
The power to start again and the fairness of the new hearing were separate issues in this appeal.
A sports club withdrew a disciplinary determination after recognising that the member had not received relevant adverse material. It then appointed a second panel, which included one person from the first. On 8 September 2026, the National Sports Tribunal quashed the second determination.
The member raised two distinct objections. In the published extract at [39]–[50], the tribunal rejected the argument that the defective first process had exhausted the club’s power to act. That left a separate question about whether the second panel could hear the narrower case fairly.
At [74]–[83], the tribunal considered the common panel member’s earlier exposure to excluded material and what the second panel’s instructions said about it. Looking at this particular process, it found a reasonable apprehension that the second panel had not approached its task with an impartial mind.
For an association planning a rehearing, the practical questions concern who saw the earlier evidence, what the new panel may consider, and what directions it receives. The public extract preserves anonymity. The tribunal has withheld the full reasons, and its procedural order makes no finding of actual bias or exoneration on the underlying allegations.

Comments