top of page

Faith, food and fairness in Queensland prisons: what changed since 2007?

21 hours ago
4 min read

BAJN • Corrections Flashbacks • ABC Radio • 12 February 2007

In February 2007, ABC Radio’s The World Today reported on a Muslim prisoner’s successful discrimination complaint over the food he was offered in Queensland custody. The practical question was whether an otherwise standard prison menu could leave a person without meals they could eat consistently with their beliefs. Interviewed for the report, Brian Newman of the Queensland Prison Officers’ Association raised the broader issue of discrimination affecting both people in custody and prison officers. Listen to the original ABC report or read the transcript.

As the Queensland Human Rights Commission’s summary of the 2006 tribunal decision records, the tribunal found both direct and indirect discrimination in the circumstances. It looked at what meals and supplements were actually supplied, how long the arrangements lasted and what alternatives the prison could reasonably provide. This was not a universal ruling that every food preference must be met. It showed why a general rule can have unequal effects.

What changed?

In 2008, Queensland added special provisions for certain discrimination complaints by offenders against correctional authorities. Under the *Corrective Services Act 2006*, chapter 6, part 12A, section 319E ordinarily requires a written internal complaint and a four-month wait before approaching the Human Rights Commissioner under the Anti-Discrimination Act, unless written notice says the chief executive has finished dealing with it. Sections 319G and 319H address reasonableness, including relevant security, operational and dignity considerations.

Queensland also introduced a distinct human rights framework. From January 2020, the *Human Rights Act 2019*, sections 13, 15, 20, 27–28, 30 and 58 protects equality, religious freedom, cultural rights and humane treatment in custody. Subject to the Act’s qualifications, public entities must act compatibly with human rights and properly consider relevant rights when making decisions. A restriction requires justification; naming a safety concern does not, by itself, explain why the chosen response was necessary.

In practice, the QCS Food and Nutrition directive, version 05, section 5 sets out a case-by-case application for cultural or religious food needs, with meals to match approved requirements. The independent Inspector’s standards 58–59 assess special diets and religious and spiritual support. These standards and policies tell us what should be checked, not how each facility performs.

If an issue arises now

Note when the request was made, the need explained, what was offered, and what written reasons were given. Check the QHRC’s guidance for people in prison early: discrimination and human rights routes have different requirements. For officers, record what occurred through authorised channels without taking or circulating confidential records.

Watch the flashback


Listen to the flashback

What’s Really Changed? • Audio discussionCorrections Flashback

Find more information: MYUNION.au


Discussion transcript

Lachie: Can a standard prison menu affect people differently? In February two thousand and seven, ABC Radio reported on a successful discrimination complaint about food offered to a Muslim prisoner in Queensland. Brian Newman, speaking in the report for the Queensland Prison Officers’ Association, also raised discrimination affecting both prisoners and prison officers.

Leanne: The Queensland Human Rights Commission’s summary says the tribunal found direct and indirect discrimination in the circumstances. It considered what meals and supplements were actually supplied, how long those arrangements lasted and what the prison could reasonably provide instead. That finding was about the specific circumstances, not a requirement to meet every food preference.

Lachie: Then the complaint process changed. Queensland added special rules in two thousand and eight for certain discrimination complaints by offenders against correctional authorities. There’s ordinarily a written internal complaint and a four-month wait before going to the Human Rights Commissioner under that route, unless written notice says the chief executive has finished dealing with it.

Leanne: The Human Rights Act is a distinct framework that took full effect in January twenty twenty. It recognises dignity in custody, equality and religious freedom. Subject to the Act’s qualifications, public entities must properly consider relevant rights when making decisions. If a limit is proposed, the question is how it’s justified in the circumstances.

Lachie: What would that look like in a day-to-day example? Say someone requests food that meets a religious requirement. The current Queensland Corrective Services food directive provides for those requests to be considered case by case, with meals to match approved requirements. So start by checking what was requested and how that request was handled.

Leanne: Exactly. Note when the request was made, what need was explained, what food was offered and any written reasons. The Inspector’s standards cover special diets and religious support, but written standards don’t tell us what each facility served. Officers should use authorised records and avoid circulating anyone’s confidential information.

Lachie: And check the complaint route early. A discrimination complaint and a human rights complaint have different requirements. A news story or tribunal decision from years ago isn’t a substitute for current Queensland Human Rights Commission guidance. The aim is a clear account of what happened and what would address the concern.

Leanne: That’s why the details on the ground matter. They help show how a decision affects the person it applies to. If you’re a Queensland prison officer, explore QPOA membership through MYUNION. The link is with this article. Check what membership covers before you join.

Lachie: To get in touch, email get help at MYUNION.au, or call thirteen hundred, six nine eight, six four six. For more guides and information, explore MYUNION.au.


Key points from the original flashback

FEBRUARY 2007 • ABC Discrimination in custody ABC’s The World Today reported on a prison discrimination case and the wider rights debate.

QUEENSLAND TODAY Dignity in detention Queensland’s Human Rights Act recognises the right to humane treatment and respect for dignity.

BEFORE DECIDING Consider the impact Subject to statutory exceptions, public entities must properly consider relevant rights when making decisions.

Speaking and spokesperson enquiries

Invite Brian AJ Newman to a formal talk, panel or event, or enquire about public speaking, guest speaking or spokesperson services. Topic, role, availability and fees are agreed before engagement.

Comments


Commenting on this post isn't available anymore. Contact the site owner for more info.

Dhanggana

Yukka Anaiwan.

​

The names, voices, photographs and images of people who have passed away may appear here.

​

Our topics speaks of death, war, dispossession, racism and sorrow.

 

Some stories may be difficult to see or hear. Please look and listen with care and respect.

​

Ngiyani winangay ganunga.

(We remember them)

DISCLAIMER

​

Brian AJ Newman does not practice as a lawyer. He is a dedicated professional Employment and Human Rights Advocate. While Brian provides expert advocacy and representation in matters related to employment and human rights, he does not offer legal services or legal advice.

 

The information provided on this website is for general informational purposes only and should not be construed as legal advice. For legal services, individuals are encouraged to consult with a legal practitioner.

© BAJN Co. 2023 

ABN:  72 947 312 445

bottom of page

Digital capability · Indigenous corporations

A website that works for your corporation.

Website development and practical website audits, starting with a free initial assessment and audit for Indigenous corporations.

Start with what you have

Tell us about your corporation, your public website and what you want it to achieve. The initial assessment helps identify priorities and the work worth doing next.

Agree the work before the price

After assessment, we agree the proposed scope, deliverables, price and timing with you before paid work begins. Website development and implementation are not included in the free initial audit.

Move forward at a practical pace

We aim for a fast turnaround, subject to the agreed scope, content, approvals and project requirements. Your expected delivery timeframe is agreed after assessment, not promised before we understand the work.

Supporting Indigenous business and future IT talent

Our aim is to help Indigenous corporations strengthen their online presence and create opportunities for young Indigenous workers to develop and excel in the growing IT sector. This is an intention for the service, not an announcement of current jobs, placements or a guaranteed employment outcome.

Hosting, information and control

Discuss your hosting and information-handling requirements during assessment. Australian service delivery does not by itself mean Australian-only data storage or processing. Website platforms and other technology providers may process information overseas. We do not promise that nothing leaves Australia.

For example, Wix explains its international processing and service providers. The appropriate platform and arrangements must be considered for each project.

Request your free initial assessment

Email gethelp@bajn.au with your corporation name, public website address (if you have one) and a brief description of your goals. Please do not send passwords, identity documents or confidential community information with an initial enquiry.