WA court applies employment-status test to earlier work: a preliminary ruling
Decision delivered: 19 November 2026. Primary reasons checked: 19 November 2026. Matter M 52/2025; Industrial Magistrate R Cosentino.
In Luke Raymond Stewart v The State of Western Australia [2026] WAIRC 01020, the WA Industrial Magistrates Court determined that section 7A of the Industrial Relations Act 1979 (WA) applies to periods of a working relationship before the provision commenced on 31 January 2025. The outcome concerns a preliminary issue, leaving the substantive employment-status and alleged contravention questions unresolved by this decision.
The reasoning and its scope
The court considered the presumption against retrospective operation, rather than treating it as irrelevant. It found a sufficiently clear contrary legislative intention in the statutory text and context. The interaction between section 7A and provisions addressing proof of historical employment relationships was part of that analysis: reasons [58]–[65] and [80]–[93].
The reasons also distinguish the Commonwealth’s transitional framework. That distinction matters: this WA construction decision should not be presented as an interchangeable rule for claims under the Fair Work Act.
Advocacy commentary: separate the propositions
There are several questions in a status dispute: which statutory scheme governs, which test applies to the period, what the evidence establishes and whether the alleged conduct satisfies the particular prohibition. Success on the second question does not establish every later proposition.
A clear case summary should identify the specific question answered and cite the operative conclusion. Label a party’s contentions as contentions. Here, the alleged misrepresentation described at [1] remains an allegation in this preliminary decision; the answer at [93] addresses section 7A’s temporal application.
Build a usable evidence record
For professional employment and human rights advocacy, connect each period in the chronology to the contractual documents and records of actual performance. Explain competing accounts and missing material. That approach makes the implications of a procedural or interpretive ruling easier to assess without overstating what it resolves.

Comments